Working Towards Inter-Religious Emancipation

In most religions, the interpretation of beliefs is left up to the men. But a group of women theologians from Germany and other European nations want to change this. Abdul-Ahmad Rashid reports

Mosque in Germany (photo: AP)
Mosque prayer rooms should be open to both sexes, the women theologians of IKETH say

​​The Inter-religious Conference of European Women Theologians, or IKETH, is a conglomeration of Muslim, Christian and Jewish women who want to take religious interpretation into their own hands.

Most religions leave theological analysis up to the men, with few exceptions such as women ministers in the Protestant church.

"Until now, dialogue among women in the church was kept at the level of exchanging recipes or pouring each other tea," said Rabeya Müller, IKETH's founding member. The German, who has converted to Islam, said women only discussed daily rituals.

"But we were rarely allowed to talk about the real fundamental theological topics, or there always had to be spiritual support from the men present," Müller said.

Not about excluding men

She added that women are still being overlooked in their religious communities. In order to battle this discrimination, Müller has gotten together with some 60 women ministers, researchers and religious academics. The new organization by no means wanted to be an elite circle.

"It's not about excluding men or making them worse," Müller said. Rather, IKETH wanted to do justice to the Koran.

"When we say the Koran is a book, which treats both genders equally, that God is a being just to both genders, then we can't in practice treat one gender unfairly," she said.

Education as a weapon against fundamentalist beliefs

But the analysis of the Koran is not IKETH's sole purpose. The holy writings of other world religions also contain many parts which could be interpreted to the detriment of women - and are.

"Wherever we have to deal with hardliners, and they are present in all monotheistic religions, we want to oppose these fundamentalist flows with a progressive approach, a different theology," said Jewish theologian Rachel Herweg, one of the IKETH directors.

According to Herweg, what will count in this case is who has the better arguments and who can win more supporters.

"I am strongly betting on education and knowledge here," Herweg said.

Worship isn't just a matter for men

For Herweg, no religion is fundamentally misogynistic. But the fact that for centuries, theological ideas were laid out by men has played a role in the often discriminatory position of religious doctrines towards women.

Women have been largely excluded from the furthering of beliefs. A striking example for women's discrimination in religion is their exclusion from the priesthood, Herweg said.

"There is still the idea in the Jewish orthodox tradition that public worship is a matter for men," she said. Progressive and reformist-liberal Jewish communities do allow women rabbis. In Christianity, only Protestants allow women to be ordained.

In Islam, the Koran does not explicitly forbid women from leading worshippers. Yet many male religious leaders argue that a woman leading prayers is only possible for all-female communities.

Müller and her colleagues are resisting the religious legitimization of this unequal treatment of women. They are taking a new look at religious texts and interpreting them in a non-discriminatory manner towards women.

In the future, IKETH and its members want to make the results of their work public with publications and congresses. They hope to strengthen women of all religions in their self-confidence.

But the organization does not intend to portray their view as the only true interpretation, Müller said. Rather, they want to stress women's right to represent a different understanding of the holy writings.

Abdul-Ahmad Rashid

&copy DEUTSCHE WELLE/DW-WORLD.DE 2005

Qantara.de

Lily Zakiyah Munir
The Koran's Spirit of Gender Equality
Lily Zakiyah Munir, Head of the "Center for Pesantren and Democracy Studies", Indonesia, argues that it is not the Koran, but social convention of patriarchal cultures that women in Islamic countries are deprived of equal social status

Dossier
Feminist Approaches to Islam
Muslim women struggling for emancipation often turn to tradition for inspiration. They analyse the Koran and the history of Islam and challenge interpretations which have been accepted for centuries